Vaccine Choice Canada

Your Child. Your Future. Your Choice.

Donate Button
  • About Vaccines
    • Vaccination: Basic Concerns
      • Children’s Health in Decline
      • Contraindications to Vaccination
      • Parent’s Guide to Vaccination
      • Adverse Events – Unreported
      • Disease Trends
    • General Issues
      • Informed Consent – Mature Minor – Ethics
      • Politics of Vaccination
      • Healthcare Worker & Student Vaccines
      • Herd Immunity
      • Doctors Speak
      • Parents Speak
      • Reports
    • Specific Vaccines
    • Vaccine Ingredients
  • Health Risks
  • Science
  • Exemptions
    • Legal Exemption Forms
    • Canadian Medical Law
    • Ontario Daycare Exemptions
    • Immunization Not Mandatory in Canada
    • Threats to Exemptions
    • Take Action / Events
  • Personal Stories
  • Alternatives
    • Alternatives – Specific Infections
  • Articles
  • Resources
    • Child Health Links
    • Pro-vaccine websites
    • Video & Audio
  • Home
  • About VCC
    • Policy Statement on Vaccination
    • Who We Are & What We Do
    • VCC History
    • Privacy Policy
    • Disclaimer
  • Join
  • Report a Reaction
  • Bookstore
  • Contact
  • Member’s Area
    • Journal Archive
  • Site Map
  • Media
You are here: Home / Specific Vaccines / Influenza Vaccine / Case-control Study Shows Flaw in Flu Shot Efficacy Assumption

Case-control Study Shows Flaw in Flu Shot Efficacy Assumption

September 29, 2008 By Vaccine Choice Canada

A University of Alberta case-control study published Sept 2008 in the American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine examined the efficacy of influenza vaccine against deaths that occur outside the flu season. In analyses which didn’t adjust for confounders, vaccinated pneumonia patients were found to be significantly less likely to die than those unvaccinated. However, when adjustments were made using all available data including that for socioeconomic status and frailty, the difference was insignificant.

Since, in a non-flu-season, the pneumonia cases examined couldn’t have been preceded by influenza, the researchers explained that the difference may have been due to a “healthy-user effect”, meaning that those who accept vaccinations are likely to be more health conscious than those who don’t. To equate acceptance of a flu shot with health consciousness is questionable; a flu shot may be seen by some as an easy way to avoid illness while continuing to live unhealthily. A more likely reason for the loss of significance when socioeconomic status and frailty were accounted for is that it is mainly these factors, not lack of vaccination, that lead to death. To his credit, co-investigator, Dean Eurich, PhD, admitted, “only about 10 percent of winter-time deaths in the United States are attributable to influenza, thus to suggest the vaccine can reduce 50% of deaths from all causes is implausible in our opinion.”

In an analysis and comment in the Oct 28, 2006 British Medical Journal, Dr Tom Jefferson stated: “A metaanalysis of inactivated vaccines in elderly people showed a gradient from no effect against influenza or influenza-like illness to a large effect (up to 60%) in preventing all-cause mortality. These findings are both counterintuitive and implausible, as other causes of death are far more prevalent in elderly people even in the winter months.15 16 It is impossible for a vaccine that does not prevent influenza to prevent its complications, including admission to hospital.

A more likely explanation for such a finding is selection bias, where one half of the study population (hemi-cohort) systematically differs from the other in one or more key characteristics.14-16 In this case, the vaccinated hemi-cohort may have been more mobile, healthy, and wealthy than the control hemi-cohort, thus explaining the differences in all-cause mortality.11 14 The same effect is seen in stronger study designs (such as cluster randomised trials) that are badly executed, which introduces bias.10 Its presence seems to be a marker of confounders that persist even after adjusting for known ones, and it makes accurate interpretation of the data difficult. Caution in interpretation should thus be the rule, not the exception. This problem (in the opposite direction—with frailer people more likely to be vaccinated) has been identified before but not heeded.17 The only way that all known and unknown confounders can be adequately controlled for is by randomisation.”

http://www.medpagetoday.com/InfectiousDisease/URItheFlu/tb/10731
http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/333/7574/912

Share this:

Filed Under: Influenza Vaccine, Specific Vaccines Tagged With: flu shot, Flu Vaccine, Influenza Vaccine

Articles by Category

  • About Vaccines
    (178)
    • Adverse Events
      (106)
    • Compensation
      (5)
    • Contraindications
      (1)
    • Herd Immunity
      (11)
    • Informed Consent – Mature Minor – Ethics
      (80)
    • Reports
      (13)
  • Disease Trends
    (27)
  • Doctors Speak
    (54)
  • Exemptions
    (166)
    • Take Action
      (108)
    • Threats to Exemptions
      (149)
  • Health Risks
    (147)
    • Anaphylaxis, Allergies, and Asthma
      (26)
    • Autism
      (55)
    • Brain and Neurological Injuries
      (37)
    • Cancer
      (3)
    • Decline in Children's Health
      (26)
    • Gulf War Syndrome
      (4)
    • Infertility
      (1)
    • Obesity and Diabetes
      (4)
    • Pregnancy – Risks to the Foetus
      (5)
    • SIDS-SBS
      (12)
  • Media
    (82)
  • Parents Speak
    (32)
  • Personal Stories
    (28)
  • Politics of Vaccination
    (39)
  • Resources
    (59)
    • Books & Periodicals
      (1)
    • PDF files
      (3)
    • Videos
      (0)
  • Specific Vaccines
    (223)
    • Chickenpox and Shingles Vaccines
      (12)
    • COVID-19 Vaccine
      (5)
    • Diphtheria, Tetanus, Pertussis, and Hib Vaccine
      (38)
    • Healthcare Worker & Student Vaccines
      (15)
    • Hepatitis-B Vaccine
      (20)
    • HPV Vaccine
      (19)
    • Influenza Vaccine
      (46)
    • Measles, Mumps, & Rubella Vaccine
      (47)
    • Meningococcal Disease Vaccine
      (9)
    • Pet Vaccines
      (1)
    • Pneumococcal Disease Vaccine
      (4)
    • Polio Vaccine
      (13)
    • Rotavirus Vaccine
      (1)
    • Smallpox Vaccine
      (4)
    • Travel Vaccines
      (1)
  • Vaccine Alternatives
    (13)
    • Vaccine Alternatives – General
      (7)
    • Vaccine Alternatives – Specific Infections
      (6)
  • Vaccine Ingredients
    (69)
    • Aluminum
      (23)
    • Biological Ingredients
      (15)
    • Chemical Ingredients
      (15)
    • Food Allergens
      (4)
    • Mercury
      (24)
    • Oil-based Adjuvants
      (11)

Join Vaccine Choice Canada

To support our educational and outreach work , please join Vaccine Choice Canada today. Sign Me Up!

Log In


Lost your password?

About Vaccine Choice Canada

Vaccine Choice Canada is a volunteer run, federally registered … read more

Our Mission

Vaccine Choice Canada (formerly VRAN) continues the work of … more

Disclaimer

The contents of this website are for informational purposes … more

Vaccine Choice Canada logo

Find More on

  • Decline in Children's Health
    (26)
  • Doctors Speak
    (54)
  • Exemptions
    (129)
  • Health Risks
    (39)
  • Parents Speak
    (32)
  • Personal Stories
    (28)
  • Resources
    (58)
  • Specific Vaccines
    (92)
  • Vaccine Alternatives
    (8)
  • Vaccine Ingredients
    (22)

Personal Stories

Susan’s Flu Vaccine Reaction

In 2013, I contracted the H1N1 strain of flu.  I was deathly … [Read More...]

My Journey with Vaccine Awareness and a closer look at Vaxxed vs. Unvaxxed

I was born in the mid 1980’s and was fully vaccinated as a … [Read More...]

A story of my grandson’s visit, discovery of his autism, and how he recovered

By Shanna Mi    November 2019 It was a glorious late … [Read More...]

Laura’s Story

July 2002 Today is my daughter's sweet 16th birthday but … [Read More...]

More Personal Stories

Featured Articles

News Nuggets – Top News Items Compiled by Edda West

February 24, 2021 FEATURES Medical Censorship & … [Read More...]

Canadian Frontline Nurses Speak Out

Kristen Nagle at the Vancouver, BC Freedom Rally February … [Read More...]

Canadian Police Associations Protest Charter Violations

by Sean Arthur Joyce January 29, 2021 “The greatest … [Read More...]

The Right To Question

Printable PDF By Ted Kuntz I’m writing in response to … [Read More...]

More News Articles

Copyright © 2021 Vaccine Choice Canada