Vaccine Choice Canada

Your Child. Your Future. Your Choice.

Donate Button
  • About Vaccines
    • Vaccination: Basic Concerns
      • Children’s Health in Decline
      • Contraindications to Vaccination
      • Parent’s Guide to Vaccination
      • Adverse Events – Unreported
      • Disease Trends
    • General Issues
      • Informed Consent – Mature Minor – Ethics
      • Politics of Vaccination
      • Healthcare Worker & Student Vaccines
      • Herd Immunity
      • Doctors Speak
      • Parents Speak
      • Reports
    • Specific Vaccines
    • Vaccine Ingredients
  • Health Risks
  • Science
  • Exemptions
    • Legal Exemption Forms
    • Canadian Medical Law
    • Ontario Daycare Exemptions
    • Immunization Not Mandatory in Canada
    • Threats to Exemptions
    • Take Action / Events
  • Personal Stories
  • Alternatives
    • Alternatives – Specific Infections
  • Articles
  • Resources
    • Child Health Links
    • Pro-vaccine websites
    • Video & Audio
  • Home
  • About VCC
    • Policy Statement on Vaccination
    • Who We Are & What We Do
    • VCC History
    • Privacy Policy
    • Disclaimer
  • Join
  • Report a Reaction
  • Bookstore
  • Contact
  • Member’s Area
    • Journal Archive
  • Site Map
  • Media
You are here: Home / Exemptions / Ontario Bill 87: A Registered Nurse’s Perspective

Ontario Bill 87: A Registered Nurse’s Perspective

May 23, 2017 By Vaccine Choice Canada

Letter to the Standing Committee on the Legislative Assembly – Posted with permission from an Ontario RN concerned about Ontario Bill 87, Protecting Patients Act, 2017, Schedule 1 Immunization of School Pupils Act


Dear Honorable Committee Members:  Please accept the following document for consideration when deliberating Schedule 1 Immunization of School Pupils Act.

Bill 87:  A Registered Nurse’s Perspective

As a front line Registered Nurse with twenty-five years of experience, I am opposed to Bill 87, Protecting Patients Act, 2017, Schedule 1 Immunization of School Pupils Act, on numerous levels. I am guided by a duty to speak out against unjust policy that not only threatens the integrity and confidentially of patient relationships, but delivers an unnecessary fiscal drain to an already overburdened health care system.

Evidence, economics, and ethics are three key pillars of progressive  health policy, with each pillar of equal importance.

Pillar of Economics:

Every day I witness the impact of budget restraints upon Ontario’s’ health care system. I see surgeries cancelled because of lack of staff and resources, vulnerable patients discharged home with complex care needs to be cared for by ill equipped family members, over used/aging medical equipment, vital medications delisted, nurses working without breaks, patients kept in hospital beds or hallways for days awaiting procedures…. sadly, I could go on. How therefore, does the province justify investing considerable funds to execute this component of Bill 87?

Bill 87s’ “education” sessions will be interpreted as patronizing and I suspect will result in nothing more than heated arguments. This Bill operates on a dated misconception that cognitive scientists have long recognized as the “backfire effect”. It is well known that challenging firmly held beliefs is counterproductive and risks such “backfire”.   Parents who decline vaccines have strongly held beliefs (entitled to them under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms). Sessions, intended to educate about risks, will not only alienate, but will likely strengthen perceptions of vaccine concerned parents and reduce vaccination intention.  Please see the evidence below to support that attempts to educate with “scientific” evidence to sway strongly held beliefs, have been failures.

Pillar broken: Economics – your plan won’t work and will waste valuable taxpayer’s money

Pillar of Evidence:

Vaccine hesitant parents are dedicated to protecting their children and perceive vaccination as a more significant risk than not vaccinating.  These parents are not societal outcasts; they are largely highly educated professionals from high socio-economic brackets who do not accept the prevailing discourse on this matter.  This should concern and not anger you. What has the government/public health officials  done to undermine their trust?   Our government should be engaging vaccine hesitant parents and addressing their concerns such as denial of vaccine injury, use of selective science, and troubling conflicts of interest with pharmaceutical companies, etc. if they wish to truly fortify public trust in vaccination.

Pillar Broken: Evidence. Vaccine hesitant parents do not accept public health evidence as transparent, honest or compelling.

Pillar of Ethics:

I am further concerned that Bill 87 operates on a coercive level to vaccine hesitant parents who may not be of a privileged class.  How will single parents, rural residents, ESL, new Canadians, or those with lower levels of education etc.  who decline vaccination interpret and manage these educational requirements? How are you ensuring vulnerable demographics will not feel coerced or intimidated by authority figures? What are future ramifications to the public trust by doing so?

The most disturbing facet of this bill however is the threat upon the sacred confidentially of a health record.  Mandated public reporting of vaccination status is alarming. This is truly not becoming of our Canadian values and warrants caution as to the precedent this sets to the confidentially of all Canadians.

Pillar Broken: Ethics – It is unethical to coerce vulnerable members of society, to betray confidentially and to penalize Canadians for exercising their Charter Rights to choice

Conclusion:

Bill 87 fails to uphold the pillars of good health policy.  The Bill fails on economics, evidence and ethics. What we really need is transparent, bipartisan discussion.  Scapegoating and questioning the rights of vaccine hesitant parents is not the means by which to accomplish that.

I thank you for your time and consideration in securing progressive health policy guided by the Charter entitlements of the citizens of Ontario and encourage you to consider the above elements of such policy when finalizing your decision.

Ontario RN  [Name removed for posting]

References:

Nyhan B., Reifler J., Richey S. & Freed G.L. (2014). Effective Messages in Vaccine Promotion: A Randomized Trial., Pediatrics, http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/pediatrics/133/4/e835.full.pdf

Crowcroft et al (2015). Do we need a better approach to making vaccine recommendations? The British Medical Journal.   Retrieved at http://www.bmj.com/bmj/section-pdf/891046?path=/bmj/350/7995/Analysis.full.pdf

Kahan D.M., Peters E., Wittlin M., Slovic P., Ouellette L.L., Braman D. & Mandel G. (2012). The polarizing impact of science literacy and numeracy on perceived climate change risks, Nature Climate Change, 2 (10) 732-735. http://scholarship.law.gwu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1298&context=faculty_publications

McRaney, D. (2014) The Backfire Effect. A Celebration of Delusion. Retrieved at https://youarenotsosmart.com/2011/06/10/the-backfire-effect/

Skurnik I., Yoon C., Park D. & Schwarz N. (2005). How Warnings about False Claims Become Recommendations, Journal of Consumer Research, 31 (4) 713-724.  http://www.rcgd.isr.umich.edu/news/Skurnik.Yoon.Park.Schwarz.2005.jofconsumer resh.pdf

Schwarz N., Sanna L.J., Skurnik I. & Yoon C. Metacognitive Experiences and The Intricacies of Setting People Straight: Implications for Debasing and Public Information Campaigns, Advances in Experimental Copyright 2007, Elsevier Inc. Social Psychology, 39 127-161. https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/41cc/3eeed553e733f7378446ee6205fcea420cac.pdf

 

Share this:

Filed Under: Exemptions, In the News, Take Action, Threats to Exemptions Tagged With: backfire effect, Bill 87, Charter of Rights and Freedoms, conflict of interest, education sessions, exemptions, health policy, Immunization of School Pupils Act, Registered Nurse, RN, selective science, vaccination status, vaccine injury

Articles by Category

  • About Vaccines
    (179)
    • Adverse Events
      (106)
    • Compensation
      (6)
    • Contraindications
      (1)
    • Herd Immunity
      (11)
    • Informed Consent – Mature Minor – Ethics
      (80)
    • Reports
      (13)
  • Disease Trends
    (27)
  • Doctors Speak
    (54)
  • Exemptions
    (171)
    • Take Action
      (111)
    • Threats to Exemptions
      (153)
  • Health Risks
    (147)
    • Anaphylaxis, Allergies, and Asthma
      (26)
    • Autism
      (55)
    • Brain and Neurological Injuries
      (37)
    • Cancer
      (3)
    • Decline in Children's Health
      (26)
    • Gulf War Syndrome
      (4)
    • Infertility
      (1)
    • Obesity and Diabetes
      (4)
    • Pregnancy – Risks to the Foetus
      (5)
    • SIDS-SBS
      (12)
  • Media
    (83)
  • Parents Speak
    (32)
  • Personal Stories
    (28)
  • Politics of Vaccination
    (40)
  • Resources
    (61)
    • Books & Periodicals
      (1)
    • PDF files
      (3)
    • Videos
      (0)
  • Specific Vaccines
    (228)
    • Chickenpox and Shingles Vaccines
      (12)
    • COVID-19 Vaccine
      (10)
    • Diphtheria, Tetanus, Pertussis, and Hib Vaccine
      (38)
    • Healthcare Worker & Student Vaccines
      (15)
    • Hepatitis-B Vaccine
      (20)
    • HPV Vaccine
      (19)
    • Influenza Vaccine
      (46)
    • Measles, Mumps, & Rubella Vaccine
      (47)
    • Meningococcal Disease Vaccine
      (9)
    • Pet Vaccines
      (1)
    • Pneumococcal Disease Vaccine
      (4)
    • Polio Vaccine
      (13)
    • Rotavirus Vaccine
      (1)
    • Smallpox Vaccine
      (4)
    • Travel Vaccines
      (1)
  • Vaccine Alternatives
    (13)
    • Vaccine Alternatives – General
      (7)
    • Vaccine Alternatives – Specific Infections
      (6)
  • Vaccine Ingredients
    (69)
    • Aluminum
      (23)
    • Biological Ingredients
      (15)
    • Chemical Ingredients
      (15)
    • Food Allergens
      (4)
    • Mercury
      (24)
    • Oil-based Adjuvants
      (11)

Join Vaccine Choice Canada

To support our educational and outreach work , please join Vaccine Choice Canada today. Sign Me Up!

Log In


Lost your password?

About Vaccine Choice Canada

Vaccine Choice Canada is a volunteer run, federally registered … read more

Our Mission

Vaccine Choice Canada (formerly VRAN) continues the work of … more

Disclaimer

The contents of this website are for informational purposes … more

Vaccine Choice Canada logo

Find More on

  • Decline in Children's Health
    (26)
  • Doctors Speak
    (54)
  • Exemptions
    (130)
  • Health Risks
    (39)
  • Parents Speak
    (32)
  • Personal Stories
    (28)
  • Resources
    (60)
  • Specific Vaccines
    (92)
  • Vaccine Alternatives
    (8)
  • Vaccine Ingredients
    (22)

Personal Stories

Susan’s Flu Vaccine Reaction

In 2013, I contracted the H1N1 strain of flu.  I was deathly … [Read More...]

My Journey with Vaccine Awareness and a closer look at Vaxxed vs. Unvaxxed

I was born in the mid 1980’s and was fully vaccinated as a … [Read More...]

A story of my grandson’s visit, discovery of his autism, and how he recovered

By Shanna Mi    November 2019 It was a glorious late … [Read More...]

Laura’s Story

July 2002 Today is my daughter's sweet 16th birthday but … [Read More...]

More Personal Stories

Featured Articles

COVID-19

COVID-19 Resources (printable) & Take Action – Letter … [Read More...]

News Nuggets April 2, 2021 – Top News Items

Compiled by Edda West FEATURES Naomi Wolf speaks to … [Read More...]

News Nuggets March 26, 2021- Top News Items

Compiled by Edda West FEATURES Vera Sharav - Holocaust … [Read More...]

Media Release – VCC Releases Recommendations for Vaccine Injury Accountability and Compensation Program

Send this press release to your local newspaper, elected … [Read More...]

More News Articles

Copyright © 2021 Vaccine Choice Canada